Cal Newport recently wrote a blog post questioning the value of ignoring gatekeepers in the publishing world. He took a quote from a podcast about self-publishing, and ran with it in the other direction. The original quote is:
The podcast that’s all about getting your words out into the world without contending with agents, publishers, or the other gatekeepers in traditional publishing.
And Cal turns this around to offer some advice on why you would want to use a traditional publisher with it’s gate keepers. This is an interesting conversation, IMO. As a self-published eBook author, published article writer for various magazines, and rejected print-book author, I’ve seen enough of both sides of the story to see benefit on both sides.
Sidebar: Read Cal’s Book
As a quick side-bar, Cal is the author of one of my favorite career book: So Good They Can’t Ignore You. If you haven’t read this one yet, you should. It dispels the myth of “do what you love” and aptly replaces it with “love what you do” early in the book, and it only gets better from there.
Why Did I Self Publish?
I tend to have an over-reaction of agreement with statements like the one you quote. But on the other hand, I also appreciate the gate keepers. I’m an aspiring author of technical books. I’ve blogged for 10 years, have published articles in print magazines and online magazines and have recently completed my first eBook which is self-published through leanpub.com. I decided to go with LeanPub and self-publishing for 2major reasons:
- I wanted to iterate the book with paying customers providing feedback on early drafts
- i wanted to avoid the gate keepers
The gatekeepers in this case, may have told me no or they may have helped me alter the concept in to something more marketable. But I wanted to avoid them, because I wanted to get something done and not worry about whether it would be a success. I just wanted to get something done.
The Market Size GateKeeper
I didn’t want to worry about whether or not the market size was large enough for a traditional publisher. This is actually one of the reasons I got rejected from a publisher, a few years ago. The idea that I pitched was not a large enough market, and even this small time publisher which I was talking to couldn’t afford to spend the time and money on a market of only ~5 to 10 thousand people.
Yes, a market of 10,000 people is a small market for publishing print books, by most standards. You have to consider the cost of acquiring a customer, conversion rates from interested in to actual customer, etc. You’ll never get 100% of your potential market to buy. It’s usually a pretty low number, percentage-wise. So it makes sense that a publisher needs to avoid small audience sizes.
The Motivation GateKeeper
I sat on the book for months, after getting started. It went nowhere while I waited for time to perfect my pitch to a publisher (that I already have a relationship with, through publishing screencasts). After sitting for so long, I decided that waiting for myself to perfect the pitch was not worth it. Even if I would get a bigger audience and produce a better book, getting it launched and getting paying customers would be more of an advantage for me. The income of paying customers helped drive me to make time for the book.
In this case, I’m the gatekeeper. I have a hard time being motivated by potential. I don’t want to spend a year writing a book or an app, with the hopes that it will sell. I want to get something done quickly, start selling it, and use the initial sales to gauge interest and opportunity. My motivation is a gate keeper, but it’s me in this case, not someone else.
Hiring My Own GateKeepers?
Having completed my Building Backbone Plugins book, I’m hoping to find a middle ground for my next book(s). What I would really like to do is hire my own gate keepers, to help me work through all of the things that a traditional publisher would do (vetting ideas, transforming mediocre in to masterful, etc, copy and structural editing, etc). I know my book could be 100x better if I would invest in these resources. But I’m ok with what I have now. It has earned $11K of income for me so far, and is still selling. It’s not huge. It’s not even 10% of my annual income. But it was a worthwhile learning experience for me, and will provide